Lesson 1.1: Problem Tree Analysis

What You Will Learn

By the end of this lesson, you'll have the skills to systematically analyze complex social problems and build a solid evidence-based foundation for your project.

🎯 Learning Objectives

By the end of this lesson, you will be able to:

βœ…

Break down complex social challenges

Systematically analyze any social issue by identifying root causes, defining the core problem clearly, and mapping consequences across different time horizons and impact levels.

βœ…

Use AI strategically for research

Leverage AI tools through the Model Context Protocol (MCP) to accelerate desk review while maintaining research rigor, source credibility, and analytical integrity.

βœ…

Build a preliminary Problem Tree

Create a structured Problem Tree that clearly separates evidence-based findings from assumptions requiring validation, providing transparency for stakeholders and funders.

βœ…

Prepare targeted validation questions

Convert assumptions into open-ended, non-leading questions that guide meaningful stakeholder conversations and community engagement in Lesson 1.2.

βœ…

Create a foundation for project design

Establish a solid analytical foundation that will inform every subsequent step: stakeholder mapping, Theory of Change, logframe development, activity design, and proposal writing.

πŸ’‘ Skills You Will Gain

Analytical Skills

  • β†’ Systems thinking: Understanding how causes, problems, and effects interconnect
  • β†’ Root cause analysis: Going 2-3 levels deep with "Why?" questioning
  • β†’ Evidence evaluation: Assessing source credibility and relevance
  • β†’ Pattern recognition: Identifying themes across multiple causes and effects

Research Skills

  • β†’ AI prompt engineering: Structuring effective prompts using the MCP framework
  • β†’ Desk review methodology: Conducting efficient secondary research
  • β†’ Source verification: Checking credibility, recency, and context fit
  • β†’ Knowledge gap identification: Recognizing what you don't know and need to validate

Communication Skills

  • β†’ Problem framing: Articulating problems without embedded causes or solutions
  • β†’ Stakeholder question design: Crafting open-ended, non-leading questions
  • β†’ Visual documentation: Creating clear tree diagrams for presentations and proposals
  • β†’ Assumption transparency: Clearly flagging what's evidence vs. what needs validation

πŸ“š Prerequisites

⏱️ Time Commitment

5 min
Video lesson
45-60 min
Supporting materials
1-2 hrs
Practice exercises
Total estimated time: 2-3 hours

πŸ“¦ What This Lesson Includes

πŸŽ₯

5-Minute Video Overview

Visual demonstration with timing markers and real examples

πŸ“Š

Problem Tree Framework

Complete guide to causes, core problem, and effects analysis

πŸ€–

AI-Assisted Research Guide

Model Context Protocol integration for desk review

πŸ“‹

Downloadable Templates

Problem Tree worksheet and validation question generator

πŸ’‘

Real-World Examples

Nigeria Youth Livelihood Problem Tree case study

βœ…

Quality Checklist

Standards for evidence-based analysis

How This Connects to Other Lessons

Problem Tree Analysis is the foundation that everything else builds on:

graph TD
    %% Foundation - Lesson 1.1
    L11["πŸ“š LESSON 1.1
Problem Tree Analysis

β€’ Define core problem
β€’ Map root causes
β€’ Identify effects
β€’ Tag evidence (E) vs assumptions (A)"] %% Module 1 - Building Foundation L12["πŸ—ΊοΈ LESSON 1.2
Stakeholder Mapping

β€’ Validate assumptions
from Problem Tree"] L13["πŸ“Š LESSON 1.3
Synthesize Data

β€’ Refine Problem Tree
with stakeholder insights"] L14["🎯 LESSON 1.4
Theory of Change

β€’ Flip Problem Tree
into positive pathway"] %% Module 2 - Operationalize MOD2["πŸš€ MODULE 2: Operationalize

Your cause-effect logic becomes
the backbone for all operations"] L21["πŸ“‹ Lesson 2.1
Logical Framework
(Causes β†’ Outputs)"] L22["βš™οΈ Lesson 2.2
Activity Design
(Target root causes)"] L23["✍️ Lesson 2.3
Proposal Writing
(Problem section ready)"] L24["πŸ’° Lesson 2.4
Budget Estimation
(Costs linked to causes)"] %% Relationships - Flow from foundation L11 --> L12 L11 --> L13 L11 --> L14 L12 --> MOD2 L13 --> MOD2 L14 --> MOD2 MOD2 --> L21 MOD2 --> L22 MOD2 --> L23 MOD2 --> L24 %% Festa Design System Colors %% Foundation - Pot of Gold (critical starting point) style L11 fill:#F59E0B,stroke:#D97706,stroke-width:4px,color:#1F2937,font-weight:bold %% Module 1 Lessons - Pepper Green (building blocks) style L12 fill:#10B981,stroke:#059669,stroke-width:2px,color:#fff style L13 fill:#10B981,stroke:#059669,stroke-width:2px,color:#fff style L14 fill:#10B981,stroke:#059669,stroke-width:2px,color:#fff %% Module 2 Container - Leaf (practical application) style MOD2 fill:#72B043,stroke:#5A8F36,stroke-width:3px,color:#fff,font-weight:bold %% Module 2 Lessons - Leaf lighter shade style L21 fill:#84C556,stroke:#72B043,stroke-width:1px,color:#fff style L22 fill:#84C556,stroke:#72B043,stroke-width:1px,color:#fff style L23 fill:#84C556,stroke:#72B043,stroke-width:1px,color:#fff style L24 fill:#84C556,stroke:#72B043,stroke-width:1px,color:#fff

πŸ’‘ The Learning Journey

Lesson 1.1 (shown in gold) is the foundational lesson that everything else builds upon. Your Problem Tree directly feeds into stakeholder validation, data synthesis, and Theory of Change. These three lessons converge to inform all Module 2 operational activitiesβ€”logframes, activities, proposals, and budgets.

⚠️ Common Pitfall

Many projects skip or rush problem analysis, jumping straight to solutions. This leads to unfocused interventions, weak proposals, and missed opportunities. Invest time hereβ€”it pays dividends throughout your project design process.

πŸš€ Ready to Start?

Ready to Start?

Now that you understand what you'll learn, move to Why This Matters to see real-world impact of strong vs. weak problem analysis, then dive into the core methodologies.